I think it's the same deer. Tine length is an illusion, IMO from the camera angles.
End of left main beam: last inch has an upturn, 2 inches before that is a "flat"
Left G3 has webbing at the base seen in both
Right G2 has a crook in the last inch
Right G3 has a crook in the last inch
The rack has the same general shape and width. The only thing that doesn't appear to line up are the tine lengths, and that's an angle issue.
And a strong clue is that the pics were taken 4 minutes apart. That's not conclusive, but Occam's razor and all....It's the same deer.